KRFL - a football simulation league
Forums
KRFL :: Forums :: KRFL Forums :: 2023 Season League Business
Proposed Rule Change: Require Durability Rating of 6 for OL, DL, DB to Count Towards Minimum Players << Previous thread | Next thread >>
Moderators: noodles, MarkB
Author Post
MarkB
Fri Mar 10 2023, 04:45p.m.
Mark Blume

Registered Member #81
Joined: Mon Oct 14 2013, 08:54a.m.

Posts: 1980
Re-proposing this. It failed last year by a vote of 12-12

See http://www.aaroncraneinstitute.com/football/e107_plugins/forum/forum_viewtopic.php?14268

Current Rule:
Rule 4.4 includes a team must carry a certain minimum number of players at each position.

Proposed Rule:
For offensive lineman, defensive lineman, and defensive backs, only players with a durability rating of six (6) or more count towards the minimum number of players at a position beginning with the 2023 season.

Explanation:
There is no minimum number of healthy players per game. I’ve seen games where teams have only 2 healthy CB or 1 healthy OT and so players have to play out of position. This proposal attempts to avoid that so that teams are more competitive by not having players play out of position. Skills positions are not included as we have minimum attempt/reception requirement for those positions.


[ Edited Fri Mar 10 2023, 04:47p.m. ]
Back to top
Salem
Fri Mar 10 2023, 06:37p.m.
Registered Member #25
Joined: Sun Sep 07 2008, 10:07p.m.

Posts: 763
I second this proposal as well.
Back to top
bfletch
Fri Mar 10 2023, 11:58p.m.
Registered Member #106
Joined: Thu Jan 05 2023, 09:47p.m.

Posts: 10
I second this proposal
Back to top
PapaBear53
Mon Mar 13 2023, 11:57a.m.
Guest

Seconded
Back to top
mark
Mon Mar 13 2023, 11:37p.m.
Registered Member #45
Joined: Wed May 05 2010, 11:29p.m.

Posts: 826
Yes
Back to top
KRFL-BayCity
Thu Mar 16 2023, 02:42p.m.
Registered Member #12
Joined: Mon Sep 01 2008, 07:40p.m.

Posts: 798
just to clarify.... would this pertain to season-opening rosters only, or would this be a requirement every week during the season
Back to top
MarkB
Thu Mar 16 2023, 09:04p.m.
Mark Blume

Registered Member #81
Joined: Mon Oct 14 2013, 08:54a.m.

Posts: 1980
KRFL-BayCity wrote ...

just to clarify.... would this pertain to season-opening rosters only, or would this be a requirement every week during the season

Rule 4.4 states:
4.4 - At the start of each game throughout the entire season (including the playoffs)

So this rule would change would fall under that.
Back to top
MarkB
Sat Mar 18 2023, 10:39a.m.
Mark Blume

Registered Member #81
Joined: Mon Oct 14 2013, 08:54a.m.

Posts: 1980
This proposal has the support of three other coaches, and will be voted on.
Back to top
MarkB
Sat Apr 01 2023, 02:12p.m.
Mark Blume

Registered Member #81
Joined: Mon Oct 14 2013, 08:54a.m.

Posts: 1980
This proposal FAILED 13-10 (15 yes votes were needed to pass, and this fell two votes short for the third season in a row.)
Back to top
 

Jump:     Back to top

Syndicate this thread: rss 0.92 Syndicate this thread: rss 2.0 Syndicate this thread: RDF
Powered by e107 Forum System